my oprah question

Friends, family, and others [must read] have had a lot to say about Oprah lately. My first response to Oprah’s Leadership Academy was that it appears to be focusing on some very high-level needs (esteem, self-actualization) when its not clear that the lower-level needs (physiological, safety) of those same children, and others in that region, are being met.

My wife said something tonight [last week…] (exactly what, I can’t remember; ironic since I was ranting about the Libby case) that made me think about the Leadership Academy another way:

Which is better (the calculations are generic so the net benefit to society is equal):

  • to make 350 children’s lives 100 times better
    (the Leadership Academy)
  • to make 3,500 children’s lives 10 times better
    (say, clean drinking water and irrigation for a community)

One potential outcome is that while society is equally better off under both options, the first option seems to create two social classes (or further divide classes if they already exist). Maybe the Leadership graduates become entrepreneurs that help their society become more productive and societal benefits compound year after year (yay!). Or maybe the Leadership grads become a ruling elite, not aiding their society as a whole but ensuring that they stay above the fray (and their offspring no doubt, who could very likely have ‘legacy’ status at the Academy; if not in official policy, at least in practice since they will be raised with the self-actualization rhetoric that the school officials look for in applicants [based on the TV interviews]).

Oh yeah, my wife’s response was “it is Oprah’s money and she should be able to do whatever she wants with it”. It’s hard for me to argue with that — it’s certainly what I defend in general. But maybe it addresses the other reason I have reservations — this seems to be more about Oprah than anything else. Maybe the Salon article jaded me. But if this was being built by an anonymous donor, do you think they would be as concerned about the asthetics — could anyone else build spa facilities into this pseudo-academic Academy and get it approved, other than Oprah? I’m guessing the students won’t use the spa much either, it’s probably only there to take care of Oprah when she visits and needs to unwind.

Parting shot:

The rules at Oprah Winfrey’s ultra-posh school at Henley-on-Klip near Johannesburg are apparently so strict they make a reformatory look like a holiday resort.

That’s the word from upset parents, who say the school rules make it difficult for them to keep contact with their children. [Full Story]

They don’t seem to understand; these girls are no longer their children, they’re Oprah’s children, the world’s children.

Advertisements

1 Comment

Filed under I believe the children are our future

One response to “my oprah question

  1. 1)Please do NOT get me started on “The Secret.” It makes me want to yak. I watched about an hour of it (simply because I felt it necessary to be educated in my opinion), and that is all I could take. You can have my password if you want to see it, as I will not be needing it. She spouts all this crap, and yet, if asked, Oprah will say she is a Christian. I wonder if I should have used a lowercase “c” there…

    2)I think, however, that it is a safe bet that the lower level needs of her leadership academy students are being met. I also am a firm believer in the adage that, in order to help someone out of a hole, you must get out first. (Grammar is muddled, but I hope you catch my drift.)

    3)Of course this is more about Oprah than anything else. Come on, did the academy really need to be launched with a prime time television special?

    4) Your wife is right, of course. The money is Oprah’s to use as she sees fit. I cannot argue that she seems to be doing her best the be a good steward of her blessings. Of course, they are not blessings, are they? If The Secret is to be believed, Ms Winfrey did it all herself.

    5) Don’t we all struggle with options when it comes to good works? Do I sponsor this child, or should I go buy socks and hats for our homeless guys under the freeway? Do we buy mom and dad something else which they definitely don’t need and probably don’t even really care to have, or do we send that money to HPI and get them a card? The only difference is that I am looking at a few thousand dollars each year, and she is working with millions.

    6) I checked out her Angel Network on Charity Navigator, and they have a four star rating for fiscal efficiency. According the their site, Oprah covers all administrative costs herself, so any monies donated go directly to program costs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s